diyDIY · 15 min15 min totalapprox. 120 kcal per tbsp

Cinnamon Butter

October 3, 2026

This starts with the Homemade Butter recipe. Make a batch first, then take a quarter of it for the cinnamon butter — the rest keeps beautifully on the counter in a butter dish. The ratio is intentional: you want the cinnamon flavour to lead, with the butter as the base rather than the star.

The brown sugar goes into the SMEG blender on the ice setting. Run it in short bursts, stirring between each pass, until you have a fine powder — no grit, no lumps. Then add cinnamon to taste. My rule is that it should almost taste like too much. That is the point. Add a small amount of vanilla sugar at the end — it does not need to be much, just enough to round out the warmth. Stir and blend the dry mix until it is fully combined.

Take your quarter portion of homemade butter and work the sugar blend in with a fork. Taste as you go. If you want it more cinnamon-forward, add more of the dry mix. If you want it more buttery, hold back. There is no wrong answer — it is yours. Spoon it into a jar, and it is ready to serve. Beautiful on a baked sweet potato, melted into the layers of a cinnamon bun, on pancakes — try it on Protein Pancakes with Blueberries & Edible Violas or Protein Pancakes — spooned over oven apples, or simply spread on warm bread.

The recipe, step by step

Fine cinnamon sugar powder in a glass jar — the blended dry mix of brown sugar, cinnamon, and vanilla sugar
Brown sugar blended to a fine powder on the ice setting — add cinnamon until it almost tastes like too much, then a whisper of vanilla sugar
Homemade butter portions in glass dishes alongside the cinnamon sugar jar and a fork, ready to combine
A quarter of the homemade butter, the dry blend, and a fork — everything you need
Finished cinnamon butter mixed in a glass bowl — rich, dark, and fragrant with cinnamon
Work the blend in with a fork and taste as you go — more cinnamon mix for a bolder flavour, less for a more buttery result

What you'll need

  • ¼ of a batch of Homemade Butter (see the Homemade Butter recipe)
  • Organic brown sugar — blended to a fine powder, to taste
  • Ground cinnamon — generously, to taste (it should almost be too much)
  • Vanilla sugar — a small amount, to taste

How to make it

  1. 1

    Make a batch of Homemade Butter first. Set aside one quarter of it for this recipe — the rest keeps on the counter in a butter dish.

  2. 2

    Add organic brown sugar to the SMEG blender. Use the ice setting and run it in short bursts, stirring between each pass, until you have a fine, even powder with no grit.

  3. 3

    Add ground cinnamon to the sugar powder — generously. Taste it. It should almost feel like too much. That is the right amount. Add a small pinch of vanilla sugar and stir to combine.

  4. 4

    Blend the dry mix briefly one more time until fully combined and uniform.

  5. 5

    Place the quarter portion of butter in a bowl. Add the cinnamon sugar blend a little at a time, working it in with a fork. Taste as you go — add more blend for a stronger cinnamon flavour, less for a more buttery result.

  6. 6

    Spoon into a jar or small dish. Serve immediately or store at room temperature. Use on baked sweet potatoes, cinnamon buns, oven apples, pancakes, or as a sweet everyday spread.

Why it works

  • Cinnamon: One of the most studied spices for blood sugar regulation — cinnamon helps slow the absorption of sugar into the bloodstream and improves insulin sensitivity. It is also naturally anti-inflammatory and rich in antioxidants. Using it generously here is not just about flavour.
  • Brown sugar: Unrefined brown sugar retains a small amount of molasses, which carries trace minerals including iron, calcium, and potassium that are stripped out of white sugar. Blending it to a powder means it incorporates evenly into the butter without any gritty texture.
  • Vanilla: Pure vanilla contains vanillin, a natural antioxidant compound. It also has a calming, slightly sweet aroma that rounds out the sharpness of cinnamon without adding much sweetness of its own. A small amount goes a long way.
  • Homemade butter: Made from 100% grass-fed heavy whipping cream, this butter carries fat-soluble vitamins A, D, E, and K2 — nutrients that are significantly higher in grass-fed dairy than in conventional. The fat also helps your body absorb the fat-soluble compounds in cinnamon more effectively.

You might also like

Share